Recall the story of Lot’s unmarried daughters who got their father drunk so that they might have children by him! Obviously not any means can be used to achieve pregnancy. “Only respect for the link between the meanings of the conjugal act and respect for the unity of the human being make possible procreation in conformity with the dignity of the human person,” Donum Vitae teaches. “I was pretty dumbfounded,” says Zweifel, who is not Catholic.
Religious response to assisted reproductive technology
Undesired embryos are routinely destroyed or used for scientific research, which kills those preborn children. The Catholic Church’s position on in vitro fertilization (IVF) is rooted in its deep commitment to the dignity of human life and the sanctity of marriage. As IVF has become a widely used solution for couples facing infertility, many Catholics and others may wonder how this procedure aligns with the teachings of the Church.
Gamete intrafallopian transfer would be one of these, or GIFT. Here, the husband and wife engage in the marital act, but use a perforated condom. And so sperm passes through the holes in the condom, but some sperm is left behind in the condom. A doctor would then take the sperm from the condom and then inject it into the wife’s fallopian tube. Now, it’s important, when IVF comes up, it’s often… We can fall into a minefield here.
Alabama Republicans introduce bills that would let IVF clinics destroy human embryos
So, we should not use someone’s fertility status as a measure to see whether they should choose the path of adoption or not. That’s something for a couple to discern, to research, to enter into a spiritual direction about because it’s a big decision. This aspect of artificial insemination and IVF may seem less tangible, but it is an important and profound one.
The conclusion was not, however, a final explicit condemnation or approval of embryo adoption for altruistic purposes, and the debate continued. Any number of morally acceptable interventions may be used to overcome infertility. For example, surgery can overcome tubal blockages in the male or female reproductive system which prevent fertilization from taking place.
The document did not judge the use of technology to overcome infertility as wrong in itself. It concluded that some methods are moral, while others—because they do violence to the dignity of the human person and the institution of marriage—are immoral. Donum Vitae reaffirmed an obligation to protect all human life when married couples use various technologies to try to have children. Without questioning the motives of those using these techniques, Donum Vitae pointed out that people can do harm to themselves and others even as they try to do what is good, that is, overcome infertility. The fundamental principle which the Church used to assess the morality of various means of overcoming infertility was a rather simple one, even if its application is sometimes difficult.
Veterans Deserve Care and Support, not Abortion, say U.S. Bishops’ President and Pro-Life Chairman
Biden and the Democrats are not the only ones voicing support for IVF in the wake of the Alabama decision. Several leading Republicans, including former president Donald Trump, have urged more legislation to broaden legal protections for IVF. Unless otherwise stated, all site content (excluding photos and “Making Sense of Bioethics” thumbnail images) is copyright © 2024, The National Catholic Bioethics Center, Broomall, PA. The NCBC is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization and all donations are tax-deductible. We must recognize the right of God alone to give life and to take it.
Alabama Senate passes IVF protection bill amid Catholic outcry
The Catechism of the Catholic Church (No. 2377) states that IVF is “morally unacceptable” because it separates the marriage act from procreation and establishes “the domination of technology” over human life. Also deemed morally wrong by the church is the use of science to evaluate, select, and reject embryos, and any attempt to manipulate the process to determine the characteristics of children to be born. In GIFT the wife’s eggs and husband’s sperm are injected together into the woman’s fallopian tubes in the hope that an embryo will result.
Creating, Freezing, and Discarding Embryos
- Children conceived through this procedure are children of God and are loved by their parents, as they should be.
- Religious response to assisted reproductive technology deals with the new challenges for traditional social and religious communities raised by modern assisted reproductive technology.
- IVF is fertilization outside the woman’s body, using sperm of the husband or another donor.
There are some infertile couples who probably wouldn’t make very good adoptive parents. There what is the catholic churchs position on ivf are families that already have five, six or seven children who might make great adoptive families. They might be a great family to adopt and they have discerned it.
- The potassium chloride kills the baby within minutes, and he or she is expelled as a “miscarriage.” If it cannot be determined that one baby is less healthy than the others, some doctors simply eliminate the baby or babies who are easiest to reach.
- But even homologous fertilization deprives human procreation of the dignity that is proper and natural to it.
- Just as predictably, this is being played up as another lurch toward the Handmaid’s Tale-like theocratic future that the end of Roe v. Wade is imagined to have set in motion.
- Each of our lives has immeasurable value from the moment of conception.
- Several leading Republicans, including former president Donald Trump, have urged more legislation to broaden legal protections for IVF.
Some have several eggs fertilized in vitro (in a glass dish) without realizing that this may lead to the destruction of these embryos or their being frozen for later experimental use. Methods such as natural procreative technology (NaPro Technology), which focus on treating the underlying bodily or hormonal issues causing infertility rather than attempting to skirt around them, are considered morally licit by the Church. Homologous insemination is when you use sperm and egg that belong just to the husband and wife.
Spiritual Warfare Prayers for Catholics
Some embryos may be discarded, frozen indefinitely, or used for research purposes, which the Church sees as equivalent to ending a human life. The Catholic Church is against IVF, deeming it ‘morally unacceptable’ because it separates the marital act from procreation and relies on technology. The Church references the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Vatican document Donum Vitae, which outline the moral distinctions concerning fertility treatments and highlight the risks of objectifying children in the IVF process. Additionally, the Church argues that IVF often leads to the commodification of human life, as embryos are created, manipulated, and sometimes discarded based on perceived desirability. This treatment of human embryos as disposable or subject to selection undermines the dignity of each human being, who is created in the image and likeness of God. However, the procedure also raises ethical concerns, particularly related to the handling of embryos.
